Posted by: noellonghurst | March 23, 2010

PhD arguments: Part 1 – The evolution of a Countercultural place

I recently finished a complete first draft of my PhD. At the moment it is a bit too long and I am about to take a knife to it. However, I thought that it would be useful to post a brief summary of the arguments that have emerged from my research.

There are two ‘sides’ to the PhD – The first is about how the Totnes area became a site of ‘countercultural’ activity. At the moment I have written two chapters on this, detailed below. Many of the posts that I have put up on this site have actually related to this side of the PhD.

If anybody would like to read the whole of either chapter I would be happy to email them a copy. Similarly, if anyone would like to agree or challenge the arguments I would also be very interested in hearing from them.

—————————-

Chapter 5: The Dartington effect

The ‘Dartington experiment’ is the primary reason that Totnes became a countercultural place.  However, it was not necessarily the direct effect of Dartington, but the ‘collision’ of Dartington and the Counterculture of the 1970s that led to the impact on Totnes. Whilst Dartington experimented with some Countercultural practices these experiments were limited and controversial within the organization. One of the key effects of Dartington was to act as a migratory driver for the ‘progressive’ middle classes.  A number of its institutions (Dartington Hall School, the College of Arts) acted in this way. The chapter therefore argues that the desire to be amongst ‘likeminded’ people was a draw to the area (value homophily). However, the research also suggests that familial homophily was also important, with migration occurring because of friends, families and personal connections.

Dartington also supported the circulation of ideas and people, bringing Countercultural ideas to the area and supporting their local circulation. It did this not only through the employment that it provided but also through the conferences and events that it put on. The local courses and literature that it produced also helped ideas to circulate.

The chapter argues that during the 1970s, underpinned by Dartington, a Countercultural milieu grew up around the Totnes and Dartington area. Much of the Countercultural practice emerged from this milieu rather than Dartington itself, although the latter did support some activities, for example through Elmgrants. Furthermore, it argues that both Dartmoor and Torquay were also significant influences on the developling milieu.

Chapter 6: The impact of a Countercultural milieu

This chapter charts the impact of the milieu. It charts the emergence of several significant strands of countercultural practice within the Totnes area:

  • Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM)
  • New Spiritual Movements
  • Radical Feminism
  • Organic Agriculture
  • Environmental Activism and Green politics
  • Peace activism
  • Hood Faire festivals
  • ‘New Age’ Travellers

One argument of this chapter (and the thesis as a whole) is that place images / myths such as ‘new age’ or ‘alternative’ obscure the diversity of countercultural practices that take place.

It goes on to argue that there have been several effects of this milieu that have all had a direct impact on Totnes itself:

1)   The emergence of  ‘place myths’ / ‘place images’ about the town / area which shape both how it is imagined and its actual material development

2)   The production of underground press and other countercultural literature in Totnes

3)   The development of Totnes as an economic ‘centre’ for various ‘alternative’ cultures

4)   Increased visibility of countercultural activity in Totnes

5)   Proliferation of  ‘countercultural’ institutions since the mid 1970s

6)   Ongoing in-migration driven by reputation and homophily

The ‘countercultural’ migration has contributed to a wider process of gentrification that has taken place in Totnes and which has led to the current disparity between house prices and wages.

Advertisement

Responses

  1. Dear Noellonghurst,

    Forgive me for my lack of technicality. I’m afraid that I don’t have the knowledge of the sociopolitical/cultural/historical influences of Totnes that you have made your work, but I cannot help wondering if you (or any other scholars that you know) have examined the parallels between Totnes, Devon and Lewes, East Sussex. Having lived in Lewes and holidayed near Totnes, I could not believe the similarities – Many quirky and alternative residents, the yuppie effect, a strong sense of community and environmental responsibility, a bohemian influence, shops selling the same type of (arty) clothes, old bookshops, ancient buildings, Elizabethan and Georgian architecture, a castle on a hill, a setting amongst rolling downs/hills. I’m sure that there must be many underlying historical factors which have shaped these ‘twin-like towns’. Although undoubtedly influenced by near neighbour Brighton, Lewes has a character of its own and much more like its westerly sibling. I’m sure that there must be other reasons behind the uncanny similarities between these almost carbon copy south coast towns – east and west.

  2. Hi Paul

    Thanks for your comment. I am aware of the similarity with Lewes but I don’t think that there has been any ‘academic’ work on Lewes itself. At least not that I have been able to find. There is a general lack of research and recognition of such places which my work is an attempt to address.

    It would be an interesting thing to compare the two and do a similar study to the one I have done here. My guess would be that there would be similar factors to those described above, although in different configurations. E.g. I would expect that some kind of proximate institutions are involved (higher education?) and that the town was also ‘conserved’ in the same way as Totnes during the 60s/70s, perhaps with the fairly early formation of a Civic Trust.

    What little work that has been done on such places also suggests that economic marginality (i.e. cheapness) / natural landscape and connectivity can also be factors.

    As you rightly point out, Brighton must also be a factor. Indeed there is a strong Brighton – Totnes connection, as you might expect. Some of the people who were involved in key Totnes projects have since moved to Brighton.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Categories

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.